gestational carrier vs surrogate what's the difference

Gestational Carrier vs. Traditional Surrogate: Is There a Difference?

When learning about surrogacy, one of the most important facts to understand is the difference between gestational carriers and traditional surrogates. While both involve growing a baby in the womb for another person(s), they are vastly different.

The Difference Between a Gestational Carrier vs. a Traditional Surrogate

A traditional surrogate shares genetics with the baby. That means the baby was conceived using the surrogate’s egg and is biologically related to the surrogate. A gestational carrier, also called gestational surrogate, has no genetic ties to the baby. That means the egg didn’t come from the surrogate herself — it came from either the baby’s intended mother or an egg donor.

When deciphering between a gestational carrier vs. traditional surrogate, the main difference is in the baby’s genetics.

Because the traditional surrogate shares DNA with the baby she’s carrying, this attachment can create legal disputes between the surrogate and the intended parent(s). That’s one of the main reasons why traditional surrogacy is rare in the U.S.

Gestational surrogacy is more common because it eliminates any biological attachment between the surrogate and the baby. Since the gestational surrogate is not the baby’s biological mother and shares no DNA with the baby, she cannot keep it.

On the legal side, the intended parent/s’ attorney will create a legal contract that outlines all parties’ responsibilities during the gestational surrogacy process. This contract also outlines custody matters for after the birth of the baby. It ensures that the surrogate relinquishes her claim to parental rights over the child following the birth. And when the baby is born, the names of any legal parents are placed on the birth certificate. They assume all responsibility for the child.

Where is Traditional Surrogacy Legal?

It’s up to individual states to set and enforce their own surrogacy laws. Because of the legal and emotional complexities that often accompany traditional surrogacy, very few states permit it. More states are open to gestational surrogacy, but even that isn’t legal everywhere.

Surrogacy laws in the state where your surrogate gives birth are what matter — not the state where you live. There are currently 47 “surro-friendly” states – that means they accept and recognize gestational surrogacy and the contract.

Who Uses Traditional Surrogacy?

While it’s true that traditional surrogacy (also called partial surrogacy or genetic surrogacy) is often more complicated than using a gestational carrier, some people opt for it. Instead of finding an egg donor, these individuals might choose traditional surrogacy:

  • Single men
  • Same-sex male couples
  • Intended mothers who cannot produce healthy eggs

While traditional surrogacy may be legal in some places and chosen by some intended parent(s), it’s uncommon. Part of the reason it’s rare is because most fertility agencies do not allow the use of traditional surrogates. Instead, many fertility agencies encourage the use of egg donors to help the intended parent(s) partner with a gestational carrier.

At The Fertility Agency, we only work with intended parent(s) who use either the intended mother or an egg donor’s eggs. Not the gestational surrogate – so the baby she carries is not genetically, or legally, related to her. This helps her to create clear emotional and legal boundaries

Surrogacy and Egg Donor Services

Since 2004, The Fertility Agency has helped bring over 1100+ babies into the world. We work with all intended parents, surrogates, and egg donors no matter their sexual preference, relationship status, ethnicity, location, etc. Our personal experiences and years of expertise provide us with the perfect balance of business and passion. Contact us for more information.

Tagged in: